Chow Fan-fu
Since the Hong Kong Chinese Orchestra first hosted the international symposium, Retrospect and Development of Modern Chinese Orchestra, in 1997, the upcoming Chinese Music Without Bounds – International Composers’ Summit marks the fifth music composition exchange in twenty years for the Orchestra. Every one of these events has been both a parade of works and sharing among composers, as well as a platform for mutual stimulation and encouragement to embark on a higher plane.
The Contradiction between the Development of Music and Artistic Creation
The development of music in the history of mankind is a cultural evolution with an element of contradiction. Music as an art form requires that the spirit it pursues and represents is the fruit of an essential experience. What the music unfolds should be ‘true’ emotions and ‘true’ perceptions. Yet the act of creating is in itself a ‘crafting’ or even ‘crafty’ process, revealing the hard fact that music, like all other art forms, is created from naught in order to present the essential truth.
At the same time, what is more intricate and complex about music is that whether the composer can touch the audience’s heart through this ‘crafting’ process is often the litmus test for the ‘truth’ value of a piece. It involves several stages: composition, performance (a second creative stage where notations are turned into acoustics and music), reaching out to the audience, and the critics’ feedback to the composer, and covers technical, aesthetic and psychological aspects.
Music has developed under the momentum of musical composition that carries this element of ‘contradiction’. In past centuries, society was simpler, and music composition was often the creative activity of composers as individuals. When a work was completed, through its public performance and critics’ review, it would lead to contact and exchange among fellow composers, whose mutual stimulation would trigger and produce a trend that would promote music development. In other words, it is a highly individual creative process that requires group facilitation. How to alleviate the contradiction between ‘individual’ and ‘group’ is paramount for forming a momentum for music development.
Self-confidence to Drive Chinese Music Forward
Once the above is established, it can be easily seen that the continued advance of music of mankind is a long and winding road that defies prediction, swayed by both subjective and objective factors. The development of Chinese music in the past century or so has in particular undergone many twists and turns. The thousand-year long history of Chinese music has been one of incorporating instruments from different ethnic groups, cultures and especially different instruments in its geographical periphery. It was only from the Qing dynasty onwards, when the country weakened, that Chinese music became ‘second-class’ to Western music, thus losing its former momentum to go forward. But in tandem with global progress, Chinese music picked up momentum again from the 1980’s onwards, giving rise to a renewed self-confidence and energy for development.
Less than a hundred years ago, Zheng Jinwen established the Datong Music Society in 1920 (its predecessor being the Qinse Xueshe established in 1918); and in 1929, he formed an orchestra which can be seen as the prototype of the full-scale Chinese music orchestra. This form of ‘new music’, born in China at a time when the tyranny of Western music was taking the country by storm, was labelled as ‘aping’ Western orchestras. But after more than a century’s explorative efforts by musicians and experience gained through failure, this kind of full-scale Chinese music ensembles, under different monikers and despite doubts and misgivings, have undoubtedly secured their footing as an important Chinese musical ‘tool’ that holds the life, emotions and faces of contemporary Chinese people.
Goals can Drive Composers
The assured status of the full-scale Chinese orchestra depends not on economic strength, nor political power, but on the quantity of mature works purpose-written for this format. Only if such musical compositions continue to give momentum to the advance of Chinese music can full-scale Chinese orchestras exist like their counterparts in the West. This is also the reason why the Western symphony orchestra has become the global ‘musical tool’ for showcasing different ethnic emotions.
At a time when society is entering the global cyber age of the 21st century, it is clear the fate of the full-scale Chinese orchestra is closely bound with music composition. In the past decade or so, the Hong Kong Chinese Orchestra has hosted the ‘International Competition for Chinese Orchestral Composition 2000’ and ‘Chinese Orchestra Composition Symposium’ (2000), the seminar ‘On the Ecology of Chinese Music in a Modern Environment and its Future Development’ (2002), and ‘The Fourth International Symposium on Chinese Music – Tradition and Evolution’ (2007). Its purpose is clear: apart from enhancing creative energy to continue with consolidation of the existential status of the full–scale Chinese orchestra, these events were important platforms for exchange to promote the development of Chinese music.
Haring Authentic Experience in the Pursuit of True Essence in Composition
As in past years, apart from providing a platform for exchange and socializing for composers from different parts of the world and individuals interested in musical composition, this ‘Chinese Music Without Bounds – International Composers’ Summit’ will encourage more concrete exchange through sharing of experience in composition. Works will be used and even demonstrated and performed live by the orchestra for analysis and interactive exchange, which is a more ‘authentic’ kind of sharing. Through this event, what is originally an individual, ‘crafting’ creative process and ‘truth-seeking’ exercise will be shared in an interactive manner, so that a collective effort can be made to explore in a more concrete way regarding orchestration, counterpoint, and even orchestra configuration and performance effect for Chinese orchestra, which still has ample room for improvement.
Besides, the discussion will probe more deeply and more concretely problems that have been overlooked but which constitute obstacles for the development of Chinese music, e.g. the reformed sound effect of Eco-Huqin on composition and orchestration, the standard configuration of modern full-scale Chinese orchestras, notation systems, performance techniques, and even standardization of Chinese and English names for instruments. Also, this event will arrange especially for orchestra musicians to share their experience of the secondary creative process of turning notation into acoustics and music. The fruit of such sharing and study will have a positive stimulating effect on Chinese orchestral compositions.
Incorporating Foreign Culture to Strengthen Momentum
Undoubtedly, the three to four hundred years of development of Western orchestras can provide useful reference for full-scale Chinese orchestras in terms of orchestration and counterpoint, or even the surge of unconventional music systems of the 20th century. More radically, some composers have paired Chinese instruments (solo) with Western symphony orchestras, and vice versa. Although some advances have been made, there is still ample room for development and exploration.
It can be said that an era of Chinese music incorporating foreign music culture to strengthen its developmental momentum has begun anew. The naming of this event as ‘Chinese Music Without Bounds’ by the HKCO is to elevate it to a level that transcends borders and barriers. It means more than the participation of foreign composers with experience of Chinese music composition to view Chinese music as an integral part of music development of all mankind. Only by doing so can Chinese music and Chinese music orchestras look forward to the arrival of a glorious hour! In any case, the achievements and catalytic effect of the symposium will have a positive effect on the upcoming international composition competition since the last International Competition for Chinese Orchestra Composition held in 2000. We can anticipate more mature Chinese orchestral works to appear.
With this wish, I dedicate this foreword to the summit.